Two Sides of the Same Coin: How Bolsonaro and Trump Explain Defeat

Supporters of Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva.
Supporters of Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva gather in downtown São Paulo to campaign for his reelection and oppose Flávio Bolsonaro. A protester holds a placard criticizing Bolsonaro’s ties to the United States, while others carry red flags. Photo: Dreamstime.

In this commentary, Niccolò Capozzi examines how populist leaders respond to electoral defeat, comparing Flávio Bolsonaro’s reaction to Brazil’s October 2026 presidential election with Donald Trump’s response to the November US midterms. Drawing on theories of populist representation and democratic legitimacy, Capozzi explores why Bolsonaro immediately alleged electoral fraud while Trump initially blamed Republican candidates before questioning the results. He argues that these contrasting strategies reflect a common populist logic: electoral defeat is attributed to manipulation, disloyal allies, or institutional failures rather than voters’ rejection. Highlighting the importance of transparent electoral institutions and parties’ acceptance of results, Capozzi warns that delegitimizing elections can undermine public trust and democratic stability.

By Niccolò Capozzi*

Within the span of two weeks, two populist forces suffered electoral defeats in Brazil and the United States: Flávio Bolsonaro in Brazil’s presidential election and Donald Trump’s Republicans in the US midterm elections. Both lost votes and political power, but their reactions differed. In Brazil, incumbent President Lula da Silva won a narrowly contested election on October 25, prompting Bolsonaro to claim that the vote had been rigged. He subsequently flew to Miami, leaving behind legal troubles in Brazil and relying on Trump’s political protection. 

Meanwhile, Republicans lost control of Congress on November 3. Before the vote, Trump had declared that Democrats could win only through electoral fraud. Following the defeat, however, he initially distanced himself from the outcome, arguing that he had not been on the ballot, before questioning the election results a week later. These contrasting reactions raise an important question: Why do populist leaders contest some electoral defeats immediately but challenge others only after a delay?

Political scientist Adam Przeworski argues that democracy depends on losing parties accepting electoral outcomes. For populist leaders who claim to represent the “real people,” however, acknowledging defeat presents a fundamental dilemma. As Jan-Werner Müller observes, such leaders struggle to recognize electoral defeat as legitimate and instead seek alternative explanations. They may allege fraud, claiming that corrupt elites have stolen the people’s vote, or attribute the loss to the failures of candidates, political allies, or their own party.

In Brazil, Lula won with around 51.8 percent of the vote, defeating Flávio Bolsonaro by a margin of 4.4 million votes. Initially, the defeated candidate criticized the extension of polling hours ordered by Supreme Court Justice Cristiano Zanin and implemented by the Superior Electoral Court (TSE). However, his campaign had itself requested the extension because of heavy rainfall, flooding, and road closures in several municipalities across São Paulo, Paraná, Minas Gerais, Rio Grande do Sul, and Santa Catarina. Moreover, votes cast after 5:00 p.m. accounted for less than 1 percent of Lula’s victory margin.

Shortly after the vote, the Brazilian Supreme Court ordered him to hand over his passports; nevertheless, he flew to Argentina, then to Ecuador, and finally ended up in Miami, where he enjoys Trump’s political protection. From the American city, he proclaimed himself ‘the true elected president of Brazil,’ called the result fraudulent without providing evidence, and thanked Trump. This story can be traced back to the Bolsonaro family, as his father, Jair Bolsonaro, also heavily criticised the reliability of electronic voting machines in 2022 and then left for Florida. He was eventually sentenced in 2025 to 27 years’ imprisonment for an attempted coup d’état. Thanks to his visa and Trump’s warm welcome for the family, it is easier to voice dissent from afar, with the full support of a powerful foreign ally.

The dynamics of the US midterm elections were different. Before the elections, Trump had already announced that the only way the Democrats could win would be by rigging the elections. He also claimed that Michele Tafoya, the Republican Senate candidate in Minnesota, could only lose if the Democrats cheated. This line of argument is a way of justifying a possible defeat in advance. After the election, the candidate lost. The Democrats took control of both the House and the Senate, dealing a major blow to the Republicans. Furthermore, even in a state like Texas, which is usually Republican, the Democrats won. Immediately after the result, there were no allegations of fraud from Trump; on the contrary, he first claimed that he was not among the candidates and that, had he been, the Republicans would have won, and subsequently attacked the Republican candidates.

In 2020, he lost the presidential election and, in that instance, as the defeat was his own, he spoke of a ‘stolen election.’ Research shows that these accusatory statements have eroded his voters’ confidence in the electoral process, and some Republican voters might believe that elections are rigged and therefore be less motivated to vote. The paradox is that, by attempting to dismiss defeats as invalid, he also risks discouraging his own voters from taking part. However, on November 9, Trump asked on Truth Social: ‘Does anybody really believe that this “election” was honest?’, without presenting any evidence. These provocative statements fell flat and stood alone, as the Republican candidates had already conceded defeat.

The choice between alleging electoral fraud and blaming internal party issues is a tactical one and depends on various factors. In the Brazilian case, Bolsonaro was able to allege electoral fraud because the margin was narrow. Trump, on the other hand, did not initially claim that the election had been rigged, and when he later did, he did not contest the figures but asked how the polls could have been so wrong. 

In Brazil, the TSE certified the result within a few hours, and the Supreme Court ordered the withdrawal of his passports. Therefore, there was no time for a fraud narrative to take hold. In the US, experts noted that the results were consistent across the country, regardless of the voting machine or method used, and that there was nothing anomalous about the way they were reported. 

Flávio’s own party acknowledged Lula’s victory, whilst he remained isolated in Miami. The Republican candidates accepted defeat and some blamed Trump. Even a commentator close to him, such as Megyn Kelly, told him, ‘Just stop.’ In short, if one’s own party does not support its leader, the challenge remains fruitless and without any concrete consequences, such as legal challenges or a refusal to recognise the winner. 

Flávio Bolsonaro lost personally, so he decided to act by mounting an immediate and total challenge. Trump, not being a candidate, initially sought to defend his image as a winner, but shortly afterwards reverted to clinging to the myth of a rigged vote.

The tactic of claiming to have been wronged or blaming others may change, but the logic remains the same: defeat never comes from the people. It is always the fault of others – such as the corrupt elite, weak candidates or inaccurate opinion polls. This is because, if the populist represents the true people, the people themselves cannot have defeated him.

Europe, too, can learn lessons from these events. A related case occurred in Romania in December 2024, when the Constitutional Court annulled the first round of the presidential election following allegations of Russian interference in favour of the far-right candidate Calin Georgescu. He called the decision a ‘coup.’ Therefore, the narrative of a ‘stolen election’ can also take hold in Europe, and the decisions of the institutions can be exploited by populists. Europe could make its electoral institutions more transparent and efficient to leave less room for allegations of vote-rigging. 

Furthermore, the established parties should acknowledge the result immediately. These two conditions are essential if the election is closely contested. From their point of view, populists never lose elections; rather, the votes are stolen from them. When the defeat is too great, they first blame others and then cast doubt on the result.


 

(*) Niccolò Capozzi graduated with a degree in Political Science and International Relations from the University of Florence and obtained a master’s degree in European Studies from Maastricht University, with a thesis on populist communication during crises. He is currently studying for the Joint Master’s in Global Economic Governance and Public Affairs at the LUISS School of Government and CIFE, based in Rome, Berlin, and Nice, and has interests in European politics, populism, political communication, and geopolitics.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest News

Category