Please cite as:
Ben Abdallah, Chahira. (2026). “Conspiracy Narratives and the Discursive Identity of ‘the Other’ in Tunisian Political Populism.” Journal of Populism Studies (JPS). November 16, 2026. https://doi.org/10.55271/JPS000133
Abstract
This research focuses on political conspiracy communication and relies on the key theoretical components of Laclau and Mouffe’s theory of populism in order to demonstrate the performative power and the persuasive appeal of conspiracy narratives in Kais Saied’s political communication. We extracted the six conspiratorial narratives that were frequently repeated in Saied’s speeches and statements covering the period from the so-called July 25 coup in 2021 to the 2024 presidential election campaign. To examine these narratives, we focus on the mechanisms of constructing the identity of the other/conspirators from three aspects: signifying practices, definitional frontiers, and the employment of passions. Our three-level analysis led us to a number of conclusions revealing that Saied’s conspiracy narratives represent a logic of simplification of political spaces. These narratives play on ambiguity, floating signifiers, and nationalist biases to create a common enemy and to make it the scapegoat responsible for the crisis. Therefore, these narratives are polarizing, divisive, and thus antagonistic. The power of conspiracy in Saied’s narratives stems from its ability to produce new meanings from existing facts and from not being locked into a fixed meaning. This is what Laclau and Mouffe call “articulation.” These narratives, loaded with moral stigmatization, have two functions: conspiratorial demonization, used to attack and delegitimize opponents, and conspiratorial mobilization, used to mobilize a more tangible “mass” of supporters through the formation of a collective identity.
Keywords: Political Conspiracy Communication, conspiracy theories, discursive identity, populism, political discourse analysis, Laclau and Mouffe’s approach
By Chahira Ben Abdallah*
Introduction
In the last decade, the return to conspiracy theory has coincided with nationalist and identity reversals driven by racism and hate. At the same time, there has been a steady increase in the diffusion of conspiracy theories in political communication. Consequently, there has been a surge in the number of studies tackling the use of conspiracy theories by political actors as a communication strategy. These studies have highlighted the fact that beliefs in conspiracy theories are very often associated with populism (Van Prooijen, 2018; Oliver & Rahn, 2016; Merkley, 2020). In fact, the hypothesis of an “elective affinity” between populism and conspiratorial ideas is old and can be traced back to the American literature on populism in the mid-1950s (Ivaldi, 2021). However, the adoption of conspiracy theories by populists in the twenty-first century is attributed to Donald Trump’s populism in the United States, which has relied heavily on conspiratorial ideas and the dissemination of fake news.
Conspiracy theories, such as those surrounding the origin of the COVID-19 virus and vaccines, as well as those related to immigration, such as the “Great Replacement” theory, have become an integral part of the ideological framework of both right-wing populist and non-populist politicians. In Italy, conspiracy theories were at the heart of the populist campaigns of the Lega as well as the M5S (Maccaferri, 2022). In France, Marine Le Pen’s party did not hesitate, during the coronavirus pandemic, to denounce the “incompetence” and “lies” of the executive authority. Likewise, in Brazil, Jair Bolsonaro’s management of the COVID-19 epidemic was very strongly marked by “scientific denialism” (Kaltwasser & Taggart, 2022).
These examples show the growing political relevance of conspiracy theories and the close connection between populism and conspiracy beliefs, “especially due to their common dichotomic nature” (Markou, 2022: 161) and “Manichean and antagonistic societal outlook” (Hameleers, 2020: 107). On that basis, our research aims to focus on the Tunisian political context in order to study “the specific case of the presidency of Kais Saied in Tunisia, which has been labelled as a form of constitutional populism integrating conspiracy theories” (Annovi, 2024: 43). We estimate that the conspiracy logic that Kais Saied frequently adopts is strategically exploited as a kind of “alternative reality” and a defense mechanism that he resorts to for strategic and pragmatic reasons.
Our analysis is based on the theory and methodological tools of the Essex School of Discourse Analysis, which examines populism as a reason/logic and considers the political opponent (other) as a central element in the analysis because it acquires a formative character in the formation of political discourse. We will rely on the key theoretical components of Laclau and Mouffe’s theory of populism: antagonism, chain of equivalence, empty signifier, and the role of passions. This discursive approach, with the aim of showing the performative power and the persuasive appeal of conspiracy narratives in Kais Saied’s political communication, enables us to understand his “conspiracy rhetoric” (Goldzwig, 2002) or “conspiratorial imagination” (Jasmin, 2009).
Despite growing academic interest in the relationship between populism and conspiracy theories, and even though some studies have touched upon “conspiratorial populism” in the case of Kais Saied (Annovi, 2024; Kahlaoui, 2024; Sayfo & Kmeczko, 2026), there are, to the best of my knowledge, no studies that have examined Kais Saied’s discourse from the perspective of Laclau and Mouffe’s method. Thus, this study wants to fill this gap by using this well-known method to look at populism (discourse theory), thereby adding to the growing number of studies about the link between populism and conspiracy stories while offering a way to use discourse theory in the study of modern political communication in the Tunisian situation.
Thus, the questions that this study deals with are the following: What are the functions of conspiracy theory rhetoric used by the populist leader Kais Saied? Did Saied succeed in giving sense to the empty signifiers associated with the concept of conspiracy and linking them to a nodal point revolving around collective identity? What are the determinants of similarity and difference that Saied’s conspiracy discourse has formulated to construct the discursive identity of the other/conspirators? How did Saied’s conspiracy discourse employ emotions to motivate feelings of hostility and resentment?
(*) Chahira Ben Abdallah is an Assistant Professor and researcher in media and communication at the Institute of Press and Information Sciences, University of Manouba, Tunisia.
Read Full JPS Article
