Assoc. Prof. Rosenfeld: The Road Back to Democratic Fair Play and Stability in the US Will Be a Long One

Associate Professor Sam Rosenfeld.

In an ECPS interview following the November 3, 2026, US midterm elections, Assoc. Prof. Sam Rosenfeld, political scientist at Colgate University and author of The Polarizers and coauthor of The Hollow Parties, examines the implications of Democratic congressional victories for American democracy. Arguing that electoral backlash against Republicans should not be mistaken for democratic restoration, Assoc. Prof. Rosenfeld warns that “democracy is never fully safeguarded.” He explores the potential weakening of Donald Trump’s personalist control over the Republican Party while emphasizing the enduring influence of the populist Long New Right. Assoc. Prof. Rosenfeld also addresses political polarization, congressional oversight, democratic-socialist organizing, and the institutional hollowness of American parties. He concludes that rebuilding civic organizations, strengthening party accountability, and restoring democratic fair play remain essential long-term challenges.

Interview by Selcuk Gultasli*

The November 3, 2026, midterm elections have reshaped American politics, delivering Democratic majorities in both chambers of Congress while President Donald Trump remains in office. Yet this electoral reversal raises fundamental questions about democratic resilience, institutional checks, and the enduring appeal of Trumpism. As Republicans confront potential internal divisions and Democrats face the challenge of translating electoral victory into effective governance, the future of American democracy remains uncertain.

In an in-depth interview with the European Center for Populism Studies (ECPS), Dr. Sam Rosenfeld, Associate Professor of Political Science at Colgate University, specializing in party politics and American political development, examines these developments through the analytical frameworks developed in The Polarizers and The Hollow Parties, coauthored with Daniel Schlozman. His central argument challenges the assumption that electoral victories necessarily translate into democratic restoration or meaningful party renewal.

“Democracy is never fully safeguarded,” Assoc. Prof. Rosenfeld cautions, emphasizing that electoral outcomes should not be confused with structural democratic resilience. He argues that Americans’ commitment to democracy remains relatively fragile, particularly when compared with their immediate economic concerns. The Democratic victory, he contends, primarily reflects a backlash against Republican governance and cost-of-living pressures rather than a fundamental transformation of American political attitudes.

Turning to Republican politics, Assoc. Prof. Rosenfeld identifies a potentially consequential development: the erosion of Trump’s personalist control over the party. He argues that Trump’s declining electoral reputation and the approaching post-Trump succession could weaken his longstanding dominance. “That, at least, is now changing,” he observes, suggesting that renewed factional competition might restore internal checks on personalized leadership.

Nevertheless, Assoc. Prof. Rosenfeld distinguishes Trump’s personalism from the deeper ideological currents of the “Long New Right,” a confrontational political tradition that predates Trump and, he argues, will survive his departure. The weakening of personalist domination therefore does not necessarily imply the disappearance of radical-right populism or the restoration of traditional Reaganite conservatism.

Assoc. Prof. Rosenfeld also emphasizes the institutional consequences of party hollowness. He advocates stronger party gatekeeping, more accountable organizational structures, revitalized local party networks, and renewed connections with organized labor and civic associations. As he explains, “we believe parties are essential to democracy.” Their revival as “stewards of democratic contestation and fair play” is indispensable to strengthening democratic institutions.

His assessment ultimately combines cautious optimism about renewed political competition with skepticism toward any definitive democratic restoration. Formal reforms, electoral defeats, and institutional safeguards remain important, but none can permanently eliminate democratic vulnerabilities.

Looking toward 2028 and beyond, Assoc. Prof. Rosenfeld’s analysis underscores a central challenge confronting American democracy: whether the weakening of Trump’s personalist dominance and the rebuilding of hollow political parties can generate durable institutional accountability, meaningful political representation, and a renewed commitment to democratic fair play.

Here is our interview with Associate Professor Sam Rosenfeld, edited lightly to enhance clarity, readability, and overall flow for publication.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest News

Category