Dr. Fizza Batool: You Need to Understand the Society to Understand Populism

Dr. Fizza Batool.

In this ECPS Voice of Youth (VoY) interview, Dr. Fizza Batool, Assistant Professor of Social Sciences at SZABIST University in Pakistan, discusses the evolution of populism studies, the methodological challenges of researching populism in diverse political contexts, and the importance of incorporating perspectives from the Global South into comparative political research. Emphasizing that “you need to understand a society in order to understand its populism,” she advocates combining qualitative interpretation with computational methods and moving beyond Western-centered frameworks. Reflecting on her research into Pakistan’s populist politics, academic mentorship, and international scholarly networks, Dr. Batool also explores the relationship between religious nationalism and populism, including her forthcoming comparative research on Pakistan and Israel, while calling for greater attention to the public demand sustaining populist movements.

Interview by Natalia Crane

As populism continues to reshape political landscapes across the world, understanding its diverse manifestations requires moving beyond Western-centered theoretical frameworks and engaging more deeply with the historical, cultural, and political contexts of individual societies. In an insightful interview for the European Center for PopulismStudies (ECPS) Voice of Youth (VoY) series, Dr. Fizza Batool, Assistant Professor of Social Sciences at the Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science and Technology (SZABIST) University in Pakistan, reflects on the intellectual, methodological, and institutional challenges confronting contemporary populism research.

Specializing in comparative politics, democratization, peace studies, and populism, Dr. Batool brings an interdisciplinary perspective shaped by more than a decade of experience in research and development. Her academic journey began unexpectedly in the natural sciences, where she studied physics, mathematics, and astronomy before transitioning to political science. Her interest in populism subsequently emerged through research on political participation and Pakistan’s evolving political landscape.

Drawing on Ernesto Laclau’s discursive approach and Francisco Panizza’s understanding of populism as a mode of identification, Dr. Batool challenges the assumption that competing theoretical traditions must be mutually exclusive. Instead, she argues that ideational, stylistic, strategic, and discursive approaches illuminate different dimensions of the same political phenomenon. Her comparative research on Zulfikar Ali Bhutto and Imran Khan further demonstrates how conventional distinctions between inclusionary and exclusionary populism can obscure the complex intersections of nationalism, religion, and socioeconomic discourse.

Central to her scholarly perspective is the conviction that “you need to understand a society in order to understand its populism.” She emphasizes that computational techniques and quantitative analysis must be complemented by qualitative interpretation and contextual knowledge. Populism in Pakistan, she explains, cannot necessarily be understood through analytical assumptions developed in Europe or the United States.

Looking ahead, Dr. Batool discusses her forthcoming research fellowship at the German Institute for Global and Area Studies (GIGA), beginning in February 2027, where she intends to investigate the relationship between religious populism and religious nationalism. Her proposed comparison of Pakistan and Israel highlights both the intellectual possibilities of cross-regional research and the mobility restrictions confronting scholars from the Global South.

She also advocates greater attention to the demand side of populism, asking why ordinary citizens develop and maintain populist attitudes rather than focusing exclusively on political leaders and their strategies.

Beyond theoretical debates, the interview addresses academic mentorship, international research networks, methodological innovation, and the obstacles facing early-career scholars. Dr. Batool stresses that research collaboration represents a “two-way learning process” through which younger scholars contribute perspectives that established researchers may overlook.

Dr. Batool’s reflections offer a compelling argument for a more globally inclusive, context-sensitive, and methodologically pluralistic study of populism—one that recognizes the distinctive experiences of societies beyond established Western democracies.

Interview with Dr. Fizza Batool lightly edited for clarity and flow.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest News

Category